Developmental evaluation of teaching quality: evidencing practice

Boyle, Fiona ORCID logo ORCID: and Cook, Elizabeth J. (2023) Developmental evaluation of teaching quality: evidencing practice. Journal of University Teaching and Learning Practice, 20 (1). p. 11.

[thumbnail of Boyle_DevelopmentalEvaluationOf.pdf]
PDF - Published Version
Available under License CC BY-NC

Download (626kB) | Preview
Official URL:


The evaluation of teaching quality and practice is increasingly important in higher education and usually done via student surveys (quantitative data) alone. Much less attention is given to teachers’ selfevaluations of teaching practice (qualitative data). This emphasis on quantitative over qualitative data can result in incomplete and biased measures of teaching quality, and inappropriate changes to educational practice, which may, in turn, negatively impact outcomes, experiences and university microcultures. In this paper, we present a case study of an international residential masters module, in rapid transition to online delivery during the COVID-19 pandemic, to demonstrate: 1) how developmental evaluation (DEval) can be used for rigorous critique of teaching practice in conjunction with student satisfaction data; and 2) how qualitative reflections on teaching practice can be transformed into justifiable evaluative evidence, using DEval theory and techniques. Our DEval approach, theorised and enacted using the community of inquiry framework, increased the teachers’ skills and confidence to plan and continually evaluate teaching-learning enhancements. We discuss the implications and benefits of DEval for teachers and universities when used to assess teaching quality. In addition, we expand on existing knowledge to provide clarification on the purposes and appearances of all levels of evaluation in higher education.

Practitioner Notes
1. It is beneficial for universities and their staff to increase evaluation skills, knowledge and practice.
2. Developmental evaluation theory and techniques can help transform teachers’ reflections and critiques of their practice into justifiable evaluative evidence, thus increasing the rigor, and subsequent use, of this rich form of data.
3. Developmental evaluation, as described in this paper, can help to build teachers’ skills and confidence in planning and evaluation for ongoing, transformative enhancements to teaching-learning.
4. Using developmental evaluation, teachers self-evaluations can be used in conjunction with student satisfaction data to address some of the current challenges of using student surveys as the primary data source in university assessment of teaching quality.

Item Type: Article
Journal / Publication Title: Journal of University Teaching and Learning Practice
Publisher: University of Wollongong and University of Tasmania, Australia
Departments: Institute of Business, Industry and Leadership > Law
Depositing User: Anna Lupton
Date Deposited: 01 Feb 2023 14:48
Last Modified: 13 Jan 2024 14:30


Downloads per month over past year

Downloads each year

Edit Item